Crystal M.

With spooky season right around the corner, I thought it’d be fun to share a list of underrated horror movies that deserve more love. Just to share a little about myself—I proudly belong to that year-round horror-loving collective. You know the type: we’ve got subscriptions to niche streaming services like Shudder and Horror by Alter, and we don’t wait for October to get our scare fix.

While the usual suspects dominate the screen every October—Michael, Freddy, Jason—I wanted to spotlight some lesser-known films and villains that often get overlooked. And just to be clear: these picks aren’t ranked in any particular order.

Hellraiser (2022)

This reboot didn’t exactly win over the critics, but I found it surprisingly enjoyable. Pinhead’s portrayal was charismatic and compelling—a fresh take that stood out from the usual slasher fare. It’s not the scariest entry in the genre, but it’s stylish, atmospheric, and worth a watch.

Killer Klowns from Outer Space (1988)

I don’t care what anyone says—this movie will always be a classic in my book. Sure, watching it now compared to the ’80s, it comes off as cheesy and campy. But that’s part of its charm. It’s hilariously bizarre, packed with memorable scenes, and doesn’t take itself too seriously. I won’t spoil the plot, but if you’re into offbeat horror with a sense of humor, this one deserves a spot on your watchlist.

Silent Hill (2006)

This movie runs a bit long, but it’s worth the time—especially for one of its most iconic sequences: the nurse scene. The eerie atmosphere throughout is what makes Silent Hill stand out. It’s unsettling in all the right ways, and if a horror movie can deliver that deep, lingering creep factor, it’s a win. The visuals are haunting, and the psychological tension keeps you hooked.

The Village (2004)

There’s something about movies set in small towns and isolated woods that always pulls me in—and The Village is no exception. It’s a bit out there, but the premise feels like something that could happen in modern day times. What really stood out to me was the plot twist at the end.

The Omen (1976)

The original Omen is a classic—and while the sequels are worth checking out, nothing quite matches the eerie impact of the first. It’s a chilling blend of religious themes and supernatural horror, with an atmosphere that keeps you uneasy from start to finish. The film delivers creepy vibes throughout, and its slow-building dread makes it a standout in the genre. One that earns its place on my list of horror essentials.

The Descent (2005)

This is one of those movies that lingers in your mind long after it ends. It made me think twice about venturing into deep, dark places. The claustrophobic setting, combined with terrifying creatures, makes for a tense and unforgettable experience. If you’re into creature features with psychological depth, this one’s a must-watch.

Benny Loves You (2019)

I’m usually not big on horror comedies, but this one won me over. The villain—a murderous plush toy named Benny—is surprisingly fierce and could give some classic horror icons a run for their money. It’s a modern film with nostalgic horror vibes, blending absurdity with genuine creepiness. One to add to your list if you’re looking for something offbeat and entertaining.

I’m keeping the list short for now—but I’m curious, have you seen any of these movies? What did you think? And what’s on your personal horror list? I’d love to hear your picks and maybe swap a few recommendations.